Branan wrote:Branan puts on his guild councilor hat
Firstly, you've been posting a few tutorials on Dustin's wiki here. While we do appreciate the work you've done, given Dustin's attitude towards the GoW, I'm really not comfortable having resources linked to his site. I'd really like to see this moved (or at least copied) to our wiki. I don't really see any issue with the files being hosted on the GoMa site, since I expect it will be around as long as we're around. We can certainly host them locally, though (and I know some people would prefer that)
I'm extremely sadden to see this posted, and unfortunately only confirms something that I have seen over the years.
My tutorials are on Dustin's wiki for the following reasons:
1) I started out hosting them at the GoMa forum due to ease of being able to edit, keep track of and add change forums and sub forums with the forum tools. However last winter, when Nyn's server crashed hard, a LOT of not only posts made by people but many of my tutorials vanished, and had to be completely written from scratch again. Making tutorials (at least tutorials that are easy to read and written on a level to make everyone understand the information) are very hard to make and take a LOT of work, were in peril. Prior to the crash in winter, I had asked Hoikas via a PM if I could post copies (not links) of my tutorials to the GoW Wiki. I never received a reply back. (recently, in another thread, he posted to someone that he had been very, very busy last year, so maybe that is why I never received a reply). Considering that adding a lot of tutorials would be a very large change to the wiki, I wanted to get permission first. Since it was not given, I assumed that it would not be okay, or would make people upset. However, after the GoMa crash, I realized that the tutorials that I had spent hours and hours on could be lost forever and did not want to see that happen. So I searched for a new home, and Dustin offered the use of his Wiki. Since that is were the UAM was hosted (and since I could not get a reply out of Hoikas) I decided his Wiki was the next logical choice as to where tutorials on creating Ages should be hosted.
2) The GoW Wiki (and web site) have gone through a major overhaul, and during that time, I thought about asking, but wanted to wait until this was finished. It was during that time, someone here posted that they'd had their permissions yanked, due to making too many changes to the GoW Wiki (I'll be the first to admit that I have no idea what the details or whole story was on that), so my next thought was "Woah. Okay, then I doubt they would appriciate me going in and making over 79 tutorial changes, 23 Blender, and 56 Max ones." The feeling I got was one of "Hostility", so I have stayed in my area where I was welcomed and not worried about pissing someone off. My perception may not be correct, but that is how it felt to me.
3) The GoW Wiki since it's over haul is VERY hard to navigate. Sorry guys, but I had someone email me last week, asking how to import Ages into Blender. My first thought was: "Why don't people just go to the GoW Wiki where it's spelled out?", so I went to the GoW Wiki so I could email the link back to this individual. It took me over 30 minutes to find the topic! To me the main page of the wiki is not very "User Friendly", but that's just my opinion. The links were purple and with my old eyes seemed to be Black text. I found the link to the Blender tutorials because I happened to move my mouse over the word PyPRP and it changed. That's the only reason I found it. I realize this is just a subjective opinion by me.
I have had other people over the years ask if they could make copies of my tutorials and post them on the GoW Wiki. Every single time I have been asked, I have always said the following: Sure! Go right ahead!
But for what ever reasons, those people have either drifted away, or just not done it.
I did post a single Max tutorial on the GoW Wiki, prior to the over haul, and discovered that the GoW Wiki's syntax is different from the UAM Wiki, for example, the UAM Wiki allows you to make pretty posts of Python coding by using this syntax:
- Code: Select all
<source lang="python">
some python coding
</source>
No idea how to do that with the GoW's Wiki. So porting my tutorials over, besides having to re-upload god knows how many pictures again, as far as I know, each tutorial would have to have the syntax edited. That is a lot of work for over 79 tutorials (it took me almost a month to port them over from the GoMa forum, and that was working everyday, including weekends on it).
Branan wrote:My other issue is with those avatar files, though. I'm assuming Cyan gave you the OK to release them, but did they give you any distribution/usage guidelines? If not, then unfortunately our advice for working with avatar clothing will have to be the same as releasing CWE builds, or anything based on the Emote file... "don't until Cyan clarifies their licensing". That's not your fault, but since you got the OK to release them I'm hoping maybe you have some light to shed on it.
The files I posted are not the original Cyan files. Cyan uses more than one for each of the avatars, 5 for the males, and 5 for the females. The Base Smoothing files are kept separate from the actual clothing files. None of the files I posted are the original files from Cyan. Instead, I ported over the bone structure from each (Male and Female) into a new Max file, and did the same for the Smoothing Base meshes, Then I put the Dummies in, just like you would have to if they were made from scratch.
I'm aware of the licensing issue with CWE, however, I was not aware of a license issue with Max files on the other hand. I did ask Mark, many, many months ago if I could share all the Avatar files with the rest of the community, especially since they had already done so with a avatar emote file. His response at that time was "Hold off on that for now." And that was many months ago. I decided to make these Max files, and not really worry about Cyan, since all I was really giving was the bone structure used by the MOUL version, and not the actual clothing meshes (there are a LOT of them).
But the files I posted are a very stripped down version of Cyans, and do not contain the clothing meshes. Good lord no. Here's a pic of just ONE of the Male files:
- Show Spoiler
The python files I posted, I modified the names of. However, as far as I know, Python is OS, so I'm not sure why anyone would have any problems with it. I mean I could have posted them, then claimed that I had made them (the only one that would have known that was not true would have been Mark himself).
In any case, I will admit to being rather confused. I have had a LOT of people here call me a "Cyan Hugger" (that's about the nicest one I can post publicly), and wished that I would have a "To Hell With Cyan" attitude, yet when I have done this (no, I did not get permission from Cyan to post my modified Max files), I suddenly find that I'm getting "spanked" for this.
It's all rather confusing I tell you. It seems like I just can't please anyone around here.
However, since a Guild Councilor has expressed their concern over the fact that My tutorials are posted on a Wiki of a individual, who has long departed the community and no longer has anything to do with it, that this guild apparently holds a grudge against (sorry, but that is what it looks like, and that is what I have seen over the years: Uru: The Community That REALLY Knows How To Hold A Grudge), or that they are not on the GoW Wiki (but apparently TheMagician's video tutorials are okay to not be on the GoW Wiki.....at least I do not remember seeing anyone being upset about those NOT being hosted by the GoW, and are some of the best tutorials I've seen), and have expressed concerns that I have posted files that I may not have permission from Cyan to post (and that still really confuses me quite a bit since apparently I can't quite find the correct way to act around here.....is it Pro Cyan, or Anti Cyan, or is it some brownian mixture inbetween.......makes my head hurt), then I do accordingly apologize and if the Guild Councilors so wish it, I will remove my links to my tutorials, so as to not upset anyone here (both from posts and my signature).
So if the Guild Councilors could tell me their wishes, I will act as soon as possible to comply with their wishes, as I do not want to make them upset, worried, angry, etc, etc.
Edited for typos.