Dot wrote:For inter-guild and wider inter-group communication, why not develop with the other guilds and groups an area on the Open Uru forum? I'm sure that JWPlatt would be happy to help with this. It would also be possible to set up a similar chat room to that in GoMa.
The reason for suggesting this central, potentially neutral, non-guild-affiliated area is that it might help overcome some explorers' antipathy to the guilds in general. It also helps to avoid the likely charge of empire building were any of the guilds to set it up in their own areas.
Edit: I forgot to say that I agree that it is essential to keep the separate guild forums for everyday working. That way, each guild can set up the system that best matches their needs.
I would rather not use JW's site. I don't think his idea is a bad, one, but if we are building an inter-guild server the guilds should be in control of the place we set it up on. It makes no sense to me to house all of our efforts on a neutral site, when it will be very obvious that the inter-guild server will be ran by the guilds directly. It sends a message that we are not confident about our collaboration. In an environment we have little control over, we put forward the appearance that we are not in control. Trust me when I tell you that when your running a game server, it is important that people understand who is in control of it. If there is any indication we aren't on top of the running of the server, certain people will take that as license to hack it or take advantage in other ways.
Unless of course we disband the guilds. Which I think would devastate any attempt to organize and consolidate the community.
You can just about ignore most of this post. I simply don't think using JW's site is a good idea, as we would be subject to his administration. I believe a foundation of all the guilds would have enough resources and motivated people to host and run it's own web space.
